in Uncategorized

Government gets to look silly on mobile phone registration.

Last January, the Department of Communications told me that it had done an extensive evaluation and decided that making people register their prepay mobile phones was a bad idea. Now the government (not so much the Department of Communications but Pat Carey, a junior minister with responsibility for drugs announced that this was ready to go ahead, in accordance with the program for government.
Now, the Department of Communications is going to investigate this again:

Minister Ryan will be discussing the question of mobile phone registration with Minister of State Carey in the coming weeks. Both Departments are conscious of the complex legal, technical and data-protection issues that surround this commitment in the Programme for Government.

The Department of Communications, in conjunction with the Department of Community, Rural and Gaeltacht Affairs will be reviewing the situation, seeking advice from the Attorney General and working to resolve them insofar as practicable.

The Government is looking at all options that can assist in the fight against illicit drugs.”

In other words, the Department is going to evaluate this idea again and then decide once again not to do it. I don’t know why these people bother making decisions at all if they are going to instantly forget about why they made them.

I wonder why the government put this policy in the program for government. It was just looking for trouble.

Write a Comment

Comment

  1. I got the same statement from the department earlier today.

    I hate it looks like group X are just replying to your direct questions when they are actually release the statement to a number of people.

Webmentions

  • Tuppenceworth.ie blog » Registering an Interest July 23, 2007

    […] Antoin O’Lachtnain, who is one of Digital Rights Ireland’s directors, had this little nugget from the Department of Communications, Marine and Natural Resources (who would actually have to mandate such a register) responding to Mr. Carey’s intellectual eruption. Minister Ryan will be discussing the question of mobile phone registration with Minister of State Carey in the coming weeks. Both Departments are conscious of the complex legal, technical and data-protection issues that surround this commitment in the Programme for Government. […]

  • dahamsta » Blog Archive » Mobile Phone Registration July 23, 2007

    […] Also see posts by Fergus, Damien, Antoin,  Daithí and TJ. […]

  • Damien Mulley » Blog Archive » Oh shag off - Mobile phone registry July 23, 2007

    […] TJ has some good things to say about the latest act of stupidity and even quotes an official Govt email which says the idea is too difficult to police. Daithí makes sense too. Fergus too. Update: Adam too. Antoin freisin. […]